Will Pierre Poilievre Quit?

No, he will have to be pushed out, in January, by gaining less than 50% of the vote at the Conservative Party leadership review. If he wins more than 50% he will claim victory and hang on.

In all of the talk about the troubles in the CPC one thing is missing. The Liberals only had a 50/50 chance of winning the last election going into it. If it were not for the actions and words of the current US president, before and during the election campaign, the Liberals could very well have lost.

They did not and Mark Carney is enjoying a rather extended honeymoon, although the Liberal Party is not. That honeymoon will end. It is as inevitable as the sun setting tonight and when it does the Liberals will likely lose any subsequent election to the CPC. You see, the Liberals have been governing on borrowed time for a couple of years and historical voting patterns will make their loss virtually inevitable next time.

Pierre Poilievre knows this. I have questioned his political acumen and instincts in the past but even he has to see that the leader of the CPC will likely be PM after the next election. So if he is that leader he will be that PM. So he is going to hang on as hard as he can, despite the short term negative impacts that will have on the CPC. As an aside, others in the CPC, who have Prime Ministerial ambitions should know the same thing which is why I am surprised that campaigns to oust him have not been more prevalent.

Of course, his hanging on could shake loose more CPC MPs who decide to cross to the Liberals, giving them a majority government. While this would hurt Mr. Poilievre in the short term it would actually allow for more time for the positive aura around PM Carney to become tarnished. Or to put it another way, if we have an election within the next 12 to 18 months the Liberals still have a 50/50 chance of winning it. If the election takes place 4 years from now they have virtually no chance. So the short-term pain would actually be to his advantage in the long run.

I am not saying that Mr. Poilievre is play 4D chess and letting all of this happen as part of some master plan. He just wants to hang on because he likes the perks and he believes, rightly, that if he does he has a very good chance of becoming PM someday. 

There is the wildcard of CPC members not deserting to the Liberals but quitting the caucus and attempting to form a conservative alternative to the CPC. Perhaps an attempt to resurrect a progressive conservative party within Canada. I do not believe this is likely to happen or whether they would be successful if they attempted it but it cannot be discounted and if they do succeed then the next election could be very interesting.

So if he receives even a small majority of the vote in January he will claim victory and stay on as leader of the CPC. He will then try to rehabilitate his image. Incidentally, assuming he is able to do so or he just decides to wait until PM Carney's popularity starts to slide it will take time so I would not expect the CPC to bring down the government anytime soon. He will find a way to allow this government to continue until he believes he can win.